
👋 G’day
Today’s brief:
HSFK profit grew less than expected
US law firms go quiet on financials
Outlook down across 74 countries
Here’s your latest, PB #{{join_number}} 👇
WORD ON THE STREET
Profit squeeze

Leaked town hall audio shows that HSF Kramer’s Aussie profit grew just 1.5% last financial year, a quarter of its 6% budget. Revenue rose 5%, billable hours fell 3% and lawyers averaged 6.5 billable hours a day, short of the seven-hour target. The result? Salary increases came in lower than last year: AFR
A global Microsoft outage knocked out Outlook across 74 countries, leaving lawyers emailless. One lawyer likened it to a “snow day”, while a Kirkland & Ellis partner had an empty inbox for the first time since 2008, so he’s “off to the pub”. So fair: NB
Big Law is going quiet on the numbers. Simpson Thacher will stop sharing its financials with The American Lawyer, following Kirkland & Ellis and Paul Weiss last month. The PE powerhouse made US$3.5bn in revenue and US$8.5m profit per equity partner in 2025: FT
PRACTICE POINTS
Privilege prevails
⚖️ Privilege: Shell Energy has fended off an alleged whistleblower’s bid to see advice from Allens, Clayton Utz and McCullough Robertson. In Quinlan v Shell Energy Operations, a former employee argued 68 privileged documents fell within the crime or fraud exception because they unlawfully revealed his identity as a whistleblower. Justice Ryan of the Queensland Supreme Court disagreed. At the time, s 1317AE of the Corporations Act didn’t expressly allow companies to reveal a whistleblower’s identity to get legal advice — that exception only arrived in 2019. Even so, the section implicitly authorised disclosure to lawyers, who are bound to keep it confidential anyway: Lawyerly
⚖️ Costs: The Australian Grand Prix Corporation has copped indemnity costs after the Victorian Court of Appeal refused it leave to appeal a $2.84m damages award. Its proposed grounds relied on arguments it never ran at trial, and some contradicted the case it did run. The Court said parties are generally bound by the forensic choices they make at trial. World Touring Melbourne also sought indemnity costs because the Corporation ignored its $5.3m Calderbank offer. That failed. The offer was a single all-in figure with no breakdown of costs or the discount offered. Global offers are fine, but the recipient must be able to assess the compromise: Mills Oakley
⚖️ Native Title: The High Court will decide how native title parties can challenge the expedited procedure, a fast-track that lets governments skip negotiating over low-impact grants like exploration tenements. Governments trigger it by flagging the procedure in a s 29 notice. Native title parties then have four months to object to the National Native Title Tribunal. In Yanunijarra Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC v State of Western Australia, the parties didn’t object in time and instead asked a court to review WA’s decision. The Full Federal Court knocked that back, finding the flag is just a procedural step and the NNTT is the only place to challenge it: Ashurst Perkins Coie
TALKING POINTS
Honey traps return

Did you hear…
Jensen Huang’s alleged affair with a suspected Beijing spy has experts warning that Cold War-style honey traps are back in vogue. Tech companies and their executives are now prime targets. ASIO estimates espionage cost the Aussie national economy $12.5bn in 2023-24: AFR
Also…
Australia and the Philippines have signed a new Defence Cooperation Agreement, boosting military infrastructure, maritime surveillance and information sharing. Albo says it’s not aimed at any one country, but the Philippines and China have clashed repeatedly in the South China Sea: Bloomberg
DEAL ROOM
Musk merger
🚀 SpaceX and Tesla, worth a combined US$3.4tn, are edging closer to what would be the biggest deal ever, with an announcement tipped for as soon as December. Boards are thrashing out terms and governance, plus how many SpaceX shares Tesla investors get: Bloomberg
🏦 HSBC is battling to sell its $20bn Australian retail deposit book, with Citi running the process, after offloading its $36bn loan book to Blackstone. The big banks, already bogged down integrating past acquisitions, would rather poach HSBC customers with better rates: AFR
🤝 EQT has reportedly agreed terms to snap up Pickles, the country’s largest marketplace for secondhand industrial assets, from Apax Partners for north of $1.5bn, with signing expected over the weekend. Mallesons is advising Apax, while JWS is acting for EQT. The deal pushes EQT’s local tally towards $20bn: AFR
SECTOR SNAPSHOT
Coal comeback

01 — 🚜 RESOURCES
Coal isn’t going anywhere yet. JPMorgan says four big coal plants owned by AGL, Origin and EnergyAustralia will likely run up to five years longer than planned to stop power prices spiking. With Snowy 2.0 delayed again and data centre demand surging, Australia’s 2035 emissions target looks shaky: AFR
02 — 🏦 FINANCE
More than 15% of NAB’s staff now work in India and Vietnam, a month after the bank announced 2,500 job cuts. At last week’s parliamentary hearing, CEO Andrew Irvine blamed a shortage of local tech talent, but MP Ed Husic wasn’t buying it, pointing to layoffs at Atlassian and Canva: Capital Brief
03 — 🏠 RETAIL & PROPERTY
Mall landlords have some big holes to fill. David Jones, now in receivership, is closing 19 stores, leaving about 180,000 sqm empty across centres owned by Scentre, GPT, Dexus and Vicinity. Kmart, TK Maxx and Aldi are tipped to move in, but refits could cost Scentre up to $1.5bn: The Australian
04 — 📱 TECH & STARTUPS
Jensen Huang is weighing a comeback as Nvidia CEO, days after resigning over reports he had affairs with a suspected Chinese spy and a subordinate. Elon Musk and other tech bosses have backed an open letter urging the board to reinstate him, but a board probe is ongoing: AFR
Until next time,
- Team PB
P.S.

